Quick answer: Garage liability answers when your shop's work hurts someone or damages their property. Garagekeepers covers customer cars while they are in your care.
Garage liability answers when your shop's work hurts someone or damages their property. Garagekeepers covers customer cars while they are in your care.
The two names sound alike, and they answer different questions. A repair shop can need both, and the place to start is knowing which one responds to what.
Garage liability
Garage liability is liability coverage built around a shop's operations. It answers claims that your business caused someone else an injury or damaged their property, for example:
- a customer slips in the waiting area
- a repair you made fails after the car leaves and causes a crash
- a part you installed damages something else
Some shops carry this as a garage policy and some as general liability written for a repair business. Either way, the question is the same: does it fit the work you do, including any towing, parts sales or used car sales?
Garagekeepers
A liability policy is written for other people's injuries and property, and it can exclude property in your care. A customer's car on your lift or your lot is exactly that. Garagekeepers is the coverage written for it: damage to customer vehicles while you have them, from things like fire, theft, vandalism or hail on the lot overnight.
Garagekeepers can be written in different ways:
- Legal liability: pays only when your shop is legally responsible for the damage
- Direct, excess: pays regardless of fault, after the customer's own auto insurance
- Direct, primary: pays regardless of fault, before the customer's own insurance
How yours is written decides what you can tell a customer when hail hits the lot and nobody was at fault.
Questions worth asking by name
- Are customer cars covered on the lot overnight, and for which causes?
- Which policy answers for a crash on a test drive?
- Is the parts runner on a business auto policy?
- Are your tools and equipment covered, including tools your employees own?
- How many customer cars can the policy cover at one time, and is that enough on your busiest day?
Workers' comp in ND and MN
In North Dakota, workers' comp comes from the state fund, WSI. In Minnesota, it is written by private insurers. A shop with employees in both states will want to look at both.
Before the next storm
Ask for garagekeepers by name and ask how yours is written. It is easier to sort out on a quiet afternoon than the morning after hail.